These articles have been retyped from when they appeared in the Wanganui Chronicle on Thursday, March 21st, 2002.
Pupil's failure stuns artists
By Paul Vettise
Student flunks out of course; Polytech snubs top artists' opinions. Claims
appeal process has been compromised.
Two high-profile Wanganui art identities have been staggered by the Wanganui
Polytechnic's assessment of a fine arts student. Internationally-acclaimed
sculptress Joan Morrell and art teacher Peter Donne have both viewed Pauline
Hudson's work at the Taupo Quay School of Arts and considered it excellent. Both
have been dumbfounded by the polytech's lowly rating - a finalgrade of D - which
has resulted in Miss Hudson failing to gain her Bachelor of Fine Arts
degree."I was impressed with the standard of work and also its uniqueness,'
Mr Donne said."In all my 40 years of teaching art to pupils of all ages and
abilities, I found Pauline's unique style and choice of subject matter something
I had never come across before. "Pauline's work is sensitive, beautiful and
quite outstanding. You can therefore imagine my surprise to learn that her work
has been assessed by tutors as D. Mr Donne said the work warranted a B plus, if
not an A. He made his opinion public in the Wanganui Chronicle Letters to the
Editor column last year, which brought a terse reply from polytech academic
manager Suzanne MacAulay. "This demonstrates Pauline Hudson is soliciting
uninformed and non-professional opinions that challenge the findings of top
professionals in the fine arts field in New Zealand,' she wrote in her report to
the polytech arbitration committee. "The publication of such a letter
indicates that Pauline Hudson has moved outside the informal and formal appeal
process of the Wanganui Polytechnic and is subject to compromising the entire
process and possible denial of a formal appeal under the aegis of the
polytechnic arbitration committee.' Suzanne MacAulay's comments were contained
in her report to the polytech arbitration committee, a paper which was released
to Miss Hudson under the Official Information Act. Mr Donne was flabbergasted by
the polytech response. "Nobody could be much higher up than me, I've been
teaching art all my life," he said. Mr Donne is an acclaimed artist in his
own right and his credentials scoff at the "Uninformed and nonprofessional'
polytechnic claims. He was the head of the Isleworth Polytech art department in
London with responsibility for 3000 students and 70 staff. He has been elected,
a Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts and a member of the Society of Graphic
Artists. He held numerous one-man and mixed exhibitions of his work in London
and Scotland before he moved to New Zealand. "Then for 15 years I was head
of the Wanganui High School art department,' Mr Donne, who also served for a
number of years on the Sarjeant Art Gallery acquisitions committee, said. He was
taken aback by the polytech stance. "I was quite stunned... all artists
work in different ways and she has a quite unique approach and for that alone
she should have been given some credit,' Mr Donne, a Turoa Art award winner,
said. "I've looked at her sketch books and everything she set out for the
examiners and in my honest opinion it was worth a B plus or an A."
Mm Morrell was also stumped by the polytech's assessment of Miss Hudson's
ability. 'I felt after all her years of work to fail her at the last minute was
very, very harsh - a one-sided opinion,' Mrs Morrell said. "There was some
emotive marking there, a very hard personal judgment." Mrs Morrell saw no
reasons for failure. "I was amazed at her diligence, in executing the work
and its layout but I was even more amazed that she had received such low marks
for it, D minus, I believe," she said.
'I believe that there needs to be some reassessment with a more objective view
of what she has endeavoured to express. "My own experience of 40 years of
the ups and downs of bronze sculpture
and fashions, my own country's acknowledgment of my judgment by awarding me with
a QSM (Queens Service Medal - ed) and 1990 commemoration award, both awards for
the arts, tells me that Pauline deserved a pass at the very least."
Politics and bias at Polytec?
By Paul Vettise
Wanganui artist Pauline Hudson is a failure in the eyes of the Wanganui
Polytechnic. Despite acclaim from at least two acknowledged leaders in their
respective artistic fields, Miss Hudson has been flunked out of the Bachelor of
Fine Arts programme. She was given a final grade of D after she had graduated
from the foundation visual arts programme as a lead-in to years one, two and
three, which she passed, of the Bachelor of Fine Arts degree. The ceramic
student's dream of her degree is in tatters and she has demanded to know why.
Miss Hudson, 35, spent five years at the polytech only to be marked out of
graduation and has exhausted her avenues of appeal with the institution. She
said her failure to graduate with the rest of her class was not graded on the
standard of her work. "There was internal politics involving personal bias
and a difference of opinion in art. 'I chose to be figurative, nowhere is it
written you have to do your work in a minimalist style but that's the style the
school likes. I chose to be different.' Miss Hudson, who had hoped to pursue a
career in teaching, admitted she was not top of the class material but is
adamant she was comfortably above the pass standard. 'I'm not saying that I'm an
amazing student but what I am saying is that I'm not a failing student - I'm of
a standard to obtain a degree," she said. So, why has Miss Hudson been
marked so low? Miss Hudson believes her troubles can be traced back to an
initial tutor, George Kojis. She had complained to polytech officialdom about
his behaviour, which she termed psychologically abusive. Mr Kojis subsequently
left the polytech. Because of their disagreements, Miss Hudson claimed members
of subsequent assessment panels were biased against her. Miss Hudson said
her stance over Ucol's involvement with the - polytech was also unpopular.
She had refused to join in a protest against the Palmerston North institute.
'They (the polytech) wanted students to march and I spoke against it." She
said her style of work was different and she had paid a hefty penalty for that.
'I did attempt at the beginning of the year to conform to their ideas of art but
that failed. 'It's the way they treat people outside the preferred style ---
I've never been able to conform." Halfway through her final year, Miss
Hudson was given an F grade, which according to her tutor, was a 'wake-up
call". Miss Hudson admits she did not take the assessment as seriously as
she should have but maintains she was told it was a bit harsh and not to worry.
'My assessment panel failed me again in November, preventing me from graduating,
and I maintain that the grades afforded me were harsh, unfair and coloured by
personal bias," Miss Hudson said. She then entered into the appeal process.
The decision of the faculty committee - of lecturer in ceramics Jonna Gibson,
glass department lecturer Claudia Borella and Marty Vreede, head of printmaking
- who originally assessed Miss Hudson's work was upheld by academic manager
Suzanne MacAulay. The assessors questioned Miss Hudson's technical skills,
focus, interpretation, use of colour commitment and proportion. She said the
criticisms were unjustified and believed the panel was unfamiliar with the
structure and/or definitions of the grading evaluation criteria. An external
moderation report was then obtained, which also found Miss Hudson's work had not
reached an adequate level of performance. The moderators -concerned were Fiona
Pardington, of the Elam School of Fine Arts, Auckland University and Andrew
Drummond, School of Fine Arts, University of Canterbury. Miss Hudson
claimed they had been influenced by the original assessors. The next step taken
by Miss Hudson was to take her case to the portfolio review committee. They met
on December 6 last year and agreed with previous findings. Original assessors
Jonna Gibson, Marty Vreede and Claudia Borella were members of the review
committee, which surprised Miss Hudson. The polytech's arbitration committee
then met in February to consider Miss Hudson's case. The committee, chaired by
Sue Westwood, upheld previous findings but did agree to undertake an internal
review of the process. "I'm now in the process of laying complaints with
the Privacy, Human Rights and the Commerce Commissions and with the New Zealand
Qualifications Authority," Miss Hudson said. Miss Hudson said her failure
to graduate was also divulged by academic manager Suzanne MacAulay in front of
the student body at the practice graduation last November before any notice had
been given to Miss Hudson. "I feel I've been publicly humiliated over this,
there's no point going back to the polytech, I'm at least as good as the lowest
student there and they graduated.'They've turned me down with no good reason l
don't have any faith their system. 'I just wanted my degree - It's what I've
worked and paid for' Miss Hudson said her student loan was running $40,000 and
was frustrated and angry. 'I feel appalled that they can let their personal
feelings run riot in this - I feel really, really disappointed in human
nature."
Polytech to review case
The Wanganui Polytechnic will next week commence an internal review of the
Pauline Hudson case. While the polytech's arbitration committee has refused to
overturn the Quay School of the Arts decision to fail Miss Hudson, it has agreed
to take a closer look at the her complaints and allegations. "She has
raised some concerns and we will be commencing a review next week,"
polytech acting chief executive Jane Barton said. "It's normal procedure
and an independent person, will follow it through. We will respond to the
concerns and if there is any validity to what she is saying the appropriate
action will be taken.' The polytech was invited to answer specific Chronicle
questions regarding Miss Hudson's case but declined.
Failed student hopes Wiccan not an issue
Pauline Hudson has for the last 16 years studied as an eclectic Wiccan -or in
more common terms as a witch.'Lots of friends of mine are happy to say they are
witches and I prefer to be open and honest,' Miss Hudson said. "If you're
secretive people think you're trying to hide something." Miss Hudson said
the Wiccan faith was a nature-based religion that recognized and celebrated the
seasons, new moons and full moons. "It's no different to being Buddhist,
Taoist or Christian. It's a belief system with a code of ethics as much as any
other." There were 2000-plus Wicca in New Zealand, according to last census
figures, and a rough estimate of 200 in Wanganui. 'Unfortunately to be a
follower of Wicca is to carry the label witch, proudly or otherwise,' Miss
Hudson said. 'With the term witch comes a cacophony of perverted
misbeliefs that can only be corrected with a patient and regular influx of
correct information into society a task particularly suited to art.' Miss Hudson
is open about her beliefs and is hopeful, but not confident, they have not been
factor in her failure to graduate from the Wanganuj Polytechnic. "I've had
it suggested to me by a number of people that it is the reason but I really hope
that they aren't that closed-minded, but I'm beginning to suspect,' she said.
Miss Hudson's Wiccan - artwork has gone on public display at the Taupo Quay
School of the Arts and she was delighted with the welcome it received. "All
my ideas are about creating Wiccan sacred space and the response from the public
was absolutely magic,' she said. "I introduced a Wiccan circle to the
public and they didn't freak - I got marvelous responses.'
By Paul Vettise